You want custom MTG proxy cards that look clean, feel consistent in sleeves, and arrive without you needing a minor in “why is my PDF 97% scale.” That’s the real bar.
And it’s why PrintMTG.com tends to win the best website for MTG proxies conversation. Not because it’s the only option, but because it’s the option that gets you from idea to game night with the least friction and the fewest weird surprises.
What “best website” actually means for custom MTG proxy cards
Most proxy-printing debates are secretly about one of these problems:
- Ordering friction
Can you paste a decklist and move on with your life, or do you have to build print sheets, export a specific format, and name 612 files like you’re organizing evidence for a trial? - In-sleeve consistency
A deck can be “high quality” and still feel off if the cut varies, corners catch, or the finish makes half the cards clump. - Custom support
Tokens, emblems, custom commanders, alt-art, “this card but with my friend’s face,” the usual wholesome nonsense. Some sites handle this cleanly. Some do not. - Print realism vs table usability
A lot of players do not need “microscope perfect.” They need “readable, consistent, and doesn’t feel like junk.”
PrintMTG is built around those practical realities.
The quick decision framework
Use this like a shortcut, not a personality test.
- If you want the best website for ordering custom MTG proxy cards with the least effort: PrintMTG
- If you want the cheapest bulk route and you don’t mind a DIY pipeline: MPC + MPC Autofill
- If you want fast turnaround with a decklist-friendly shop: PrintingProxies
- If you want to spend more time designing than ordering:cards (then print)
- If you want specialty options like foil from a proxy-first shop: Mythic Black Core (worth comparing)
Now let’s talk about why PrintMTG is the all-around winner for most people.
Why PrintMTG is the best website for ordering custom MTG proxy cards (for most players)
1) The ordering flow is built for MTG players, not generic printing customers
PrintMTG’s core workflow is simple on purpose:
- upload or paste a decklist
- pick set versions and quantities
- review pricing as you go
- checkout
No minimums, tiered pricing that drops with volume, and it’s designed around “I’m printing a Commander deck” rather than “I’m producing a custom product catalog.” The site even calls out common use cases like playtesting, Cube, and Commander nights, which is exactly what most people are doing.
2) “Feels right in sleeves” is treated like a requirement, not a bonus
PrintMTG leans hard into the stuff that actually changes the tactile experience:
- Black-core playing-card stock (they specifically call out S33 German Black Core on-site)
- UV coating with a matte-satin feel (less drag, more durability, better shuffle feel)
- Consistency in cutting and cornering, because one slightly off corner will annoy you forever
That finishing stack matters. A lot of proxy disappointment comes from a deck that looks fine, but shuffles like a stack of receipts.
3) It’s actually good for custom cards, not just “print existing cards”
Custom MTG proxy cards usually means one of two things:
- You’re printing normal MTG cards for playtesting (decklist printing)
- You’re printing custom designs (tokens, emblems, altered frames, fully custom cards)
PrintMTG supports both. They have a Card Maker with templates and frames, plus the ability to upload your own art. On the legacy Card Maker page, they even call out support for very high-resolution art uploads (up to 1200 dpi) for crisp results.
That’s a real differentiator vs “printer sites” that technically can print anything, but make you do all the work to get there.
4) They’re transparent about “close match” goals
PrintMTG positions their output as close-match proxies for clean play in sleeves, not “perfect replicas.” For most casual play and testing, that’s the sweet spot: readable, consistent, durable, and not trying to win a forensic lab contest.
PrintMTG vs the other options
| Option | Best for | What you give up | Reality check |
| PrintMTG | Easiest “decklist to sleeves” experience with consistent feel | You’re paying for convenience + finish consistency | Premium black-core stock, UV-coated finish, consistent cutting, no minimums |
| ProxyMTG | Simple print-on-demand deck printing (upload a decklist or search cards) with a clean checkout flow | Less “simple process” emphasis than PrintMTG; custom builder features may be more limited/rolling out | Decklist upload + card search; positioned as high-quality proxies for casual play; “design your own” builder is a stated roadmap item |
| PrintingProxies | Speed-first, decklist-friendly ordering when you need cards quickly | More speed-focused; less of the premium/consistency feel compared to PrintMTG | Claims S33 black core and next-day processing; solid for fast turnaround, not the top pick for “best-in-sleeves” refinement |
| MPC + MPC Autofill | Budget bulk printing, DIY control freaks (affectionate) | You do file prep and you own the consequences | MPC is a general custom card manufacturer; Autofill helps make it proxy-friendly |
| mtg.cards | Designing custom cards fast with high-res exports | You still need a print path | They explicitly offer high-res downloads and can route to PrintMTG for printing |
| Mythic Black Core | Proxy-first shop that advertises foil options | Still worth comparing consistency, turnaround, and finish preferences | They claim on-demand printing, foil proxies, and a decklist flow |
Competitors worth considering (and what they’re actually decent for)
A good “best” list still admits other tools exist.
- PrintingProxies: If your main goal is quick processing and a decklist-friendly workflow, they’re positioned for that.
- MakePlayingCards (MPC): Great if you’re printing in bulk and you like controlling every detail. MPC is a long-running custom playing card manufacturer with lots of stock and finish options, but it’s not MTG-specific.
- MPC Autofill: The bridge between “MPC is a generic printer” and “I want this to behave like an MTG proxy pipeline.”
- cards: More design-centric. Good for custom commanders, tokens, and “I need this to look like it belongs in my deck’s vibe.” Then you print the files.
- Proxxied: A free DIY layout tool. Useful if you’re home-printing or building export-ready sheets without reinventing the wheel.
- Mythic Black Core: Worth a look if foil is your priority and you want a proxy-first storefront.
- ProxyKing: A catalog-style proxy shop that emphasizes realism and also points users to PrintMTG for “close-match” printing of basically any card.
A small checklist before you order (works no matter where you print)
- Decide your goal: full deck, a few staples, or custom designs. Different workflows make sense for each.
- Pick one “look” and stick to it: mixing frames and wildly different art sources is the #1 way decks end up feeling inconsistent.
- If you’re uploading art, go high-res: low-res art will look low-res, and it will not become high-res just because you believed in it.
- Plan for consistency: order from the same place for the same deck over time if you care about matching.
- Don’t gamble on the deadline: if you need cards by a specific date, choose a faster shipping option rather than praying to the USPS gods.
Bottom line
If you’re trying to find the best website for ordering custom MTG proxy cards, PrintMTG is the strongest all-around pick because it nails the boring-but-important stuff: ordering flow, consistent finish, consistent cutting, and a real path for custom designs.
And the best part is you don’t have to become a part-time print technician to get good results. Unless you want to. Some people truly love pain.
